Should I Leave My TSP or Roll It Over to an IRA?
Written by Josh Belcher, Great Plains Wealth Partners (Wichita, KS).
Throughout your federal career, a lot of this was handled for you. Contributions came out of your paycheck automatically. The fund choices were simple. Your agency’s HR office handled the paperwork. Then retirement arrives, and suddenly you’re the one making the decisions: how to take money out of your Thrift Savings Plan (TSP), when, and whether to leave it where it is.
If you’re a federal employee or retiree in Wichita or south-central Kansas, this guide is for you. It is not trying to sell you anything. It lays out your options, what each costs, which decisions are hard to undo, and what’s worth settling before you retire.
Start Here: The Short Version
Leaving your money in the TSP is a legitimate choice. It is very low-cost and simple.
Moving it to an IRA offers more flexibility, but it may cost more, and it can end the age 55 penalty exception.
Your pension and Social Security change what your TSP needs to do. Start with the whole picture.
Some choices are hard to reverse, so decide before you separate from service, not after.
Should I Leave My Money in the TSP or Roll It Over to an IRA?
There is no one right answer, and anyone who gives you one without looking at your situation is guessing. The answer depends on how much you need from the TSP, when you need it, your other income, your taxes, and how much help you want. The sections below walk through each piece.
Start With the Whole Picture, Not Just the TSP
Most federal retirees rely on three sources of income:
Your pension (FERS or CSRS), which is a lifetime income stream.
Social Security, also lifetime income, with its own claiming-age decision.
Your TSP, which is the part you control, and the part with the most decisions.
Because a pension and Social Security already provide guaranteed lifetime income, the question for your TSP is often not “how do I create income?” but “what do I want this money to do?” It might cover the gap before Social Security begins, pay for travel or health costs, leave something to family, or stay invested for later.
If you retire before 62 under FERS, you may also be eligible for the FERS supplement, a payment that helps bridge the gap until Social Security. Ask your agency HR office or check opm.gov, since it can change how much you need to draw from your TSP in the early years.
What Does the TSP Do Well?
The TSP is known for its low costs. Its own annual review of 2025 administrative expenses puts them at a few hundredths of one percent, roughly $34 to $43 per $100,000 invested per year. The lineup is simple: five core funds (a short-term government securities fund plus stock and bond index funds) and eleven Lifecycle funds that blend them. Many retirees are comfortable with it.
That sets a high bar. Any alternative should be able to explain what you get for paying more.
What Are My Main Options at Retirement?
1. Leave it in the TSP
What it is: Keep your balance invested in the plan.
Main upside: Very low cost; simple.
Main trade-off: Fewer investment and withdrawal choices than an IRA.
2. Partial or installment withdrawals
What it is: Take some money, or regular payments, while the rest stays invested.
Main upside: Flexible income without leaving the plan.
Main trade-off: Withdrawals from a traditional balance are taxed as ordinary income.
3. TSP annuity
What it is: Use some or all of your balance to buy lifetime income through the plan.
Main upside: Predictable income.
Main trade-off: Generally irrevocable once purchased.
4. Roll over to an IRA
What it is: Move some or all of your balance to a traditional or Roth IRA.
Main upside: More investment and withdrawal options.
Main trade-off: Costs may be higher; you may lose protections specific to the TSP, such as the age 55 rule below.
5. Combination
What it is: For example, part stays, part is rolled over.
Main upside: Match each piece of money to a purpose.
Main trade-off: More moving parts to track.
TSP withdrawal options have been expanding, so confirm what’s available now at tsp.gov before deciding.
How Do TSP and IRA Withdrawals Actually Differ?
Beyond the big choices, a few practical differences affect day-to-day life in retirement:
Investment choices
TSP: Five core funds and eleven Lifecycle funds; eligible participants can also use a mutual fund window for a portion of their balance (see tsp.gov for eligibility and costs).
IRA: Generally many more choices, which is useful for some people and overwhelming for others.
Which investments get sold
TSP: Withdrawals are taken proportionally from all the funds you hold. You can choose traditional money only, Roth money only, or a proportional mix.
IRA: You generally choose which investments to sell.
Tax withholding
TSP: Many payments made directly to you are subject to mandatory 20% federal withholding (a direct rollover to an IRA avoids it).
IRA: You generally choose how much is withheld.
Early access
TSP: No 10% penalty on traditional withdrawals if you separate in or after the year you turn 55.
IRA: Generally a 10% penalty before age 59½.
Cost
TSP: Roughly $34–$43 per $100,000 per year in administrative expenses (2025).
IRA: Varies widely by funds and any advisory fee.
More choice and more control are not automatically better. They are better if you will use them, and they often come with higher costs.
What Is the Age 55 Rule?
If you separate from federal service during or after the year you turn 55, you can generally take money from your traditional TSP without the 10% early withdrawal penalty, even if you’re younger than 59½. (Certain public safety employees and others may qualify earlier.)
An IRA doesn’t work that way. If you plan to retire in your mid-50s and might need this money, rolling everything out of the TSP could remove a useful option. Some people roll over only part of their balance for this reason.
What About Taxes, Including in Kansas?
Withdrawals from a traditional TSP balance are taxed as ordinary income, unless you roll the money into a traditional IRA, where tax is deferred until you withdraw it.
Qualified withdrawals from a Roth TSP balance are not taxed.
Required minimum distributions begin at age 73 if you were born from 1951 through 1959, and at age 75 if you were born in 1960 or later.
Since January 2026, the TSP lets eligible participants convert traditional balances to Roth inside the plan. A conversion is taxable in the year you do it, and the TSP itself recommends talking to a tax advisor first.
A Kansas question worth asking. Kansas has its own income tax rules for retirement income, and they don’t always match the federal rules. If you live in Kansas, ask a tax professional, or check with the Kansas Department of Revenue, how the state treats TSP withdrawals compared with IRA withdrawals before you decide. The answer could matter.
What If Someone Suggests Rolling Into an Annuity?
Annuities can be a sound part of a retirement plan for some people. They also come in many forms with very different costs, so ask anyone recommending one:
What gap does it fill? With a pension and Social Security, how much more guaranteed income do you actually need?
What does it cost? Ask for every fee in writing, including surrender charges, rider fees, and underlying investment costs.
Can I change my mind? Understand how much money would be locked up, and for how long.
How is the person recommending it paid? Commissions and other compensation can create conflicts worth knowing about.
How does it compare with the TSP annuity? Ask for a side-by-side comparison using real quotes.
How strong is the insurance company? An annuity’s guarantees depend on the insurer’s ability to pay.
What Would It Cost, in Dollars?
As a hypothetical illustration, on a $500,000 balance, the approximate annual cost would be:
TSP administrative costs (about $34–$43 per $100,000): roughly $170–$215
An IRA with an all-in cost of 1.0% (hypothetical): $5,000
This is a simplified illustration, not a projection and not a statement about any specific provider; actual costs vary widely. A higher cost isn’t automatically a bad deal if it buys planning, tax coordination, or income-management help you will use. But it’s a cost you should see in dollars before deciding.
What Should I Do in the Years Before I Retire?
About 5 years out
If you want your health coverage to continue into retirement, confirm you’ll meet the FEHB requirement of being enrolled for the five years before you retire. Ask your HR office to confirm your own situation.
Get a pension estimate and a Social Security estimate.
Look at how much of your TSP is traditional versus Roth.
2 to 3 years out
Sketch your expected retirement spending and compare it with your pension and Social Security.
Decide whether part of your TSP is meant to bridge the years before Social Security.
If you’re near 55, check whether the age 55 rule affects your timing.
Your retirement year
Review your TSP withdrawal options before you separate, since some choices are hard to change afterward.
Coordinate your tax plan: when to start withdrawals, and whether any Roth conversions make sense.
After you retire
Revisit your plan each year, including required distributions once they begin.
What Should I Ask Any Advisor?
What is my all-in cost, including advisory fees, fund expenses, and any product charges?
What standard of care applies to your recommendation, and how are you compensated?
Why would moving this money, or part of it, be better than leaving it in the TSP?
What would I give up by moving it, including the age 55 rule?
Which parts of this decision can I reverse, and which can’t I?
The Bottom Line
The TSP is low-cost and simple, and it deserves a place among your options. Moving some or all of it can make sense when you want flexibility, planning support, or income strategies the plan doesn’t offer, but those benefits need to be weighed against costs and the rules you’d give up. The decisions are easier when you see the whole picture first, compare options in dollars, and get everything in writing before you act.
If you’re a federal employee or retiree in the Wichita area and would like a complimentary, no-obligation review of your TSP options, Great Plains Wealth Partners offers one. We’ll walk through your choices, including leaving the money where it is.Options at Retirement?
Investment advice offered through Convergence Financial, LLC, a registered investment advisor. Supervised by Convergence Financial, 3919 S. Providence, Columbia, MO 65203. Great Plains Wealth Partners is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Thrift Savings Plan, the Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board, the U.S. Office of Personnel Management, or any government agency. This material is for educational purposes only and does not constitute individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Rules and figures change; confirm current information at tsp.gov and opm.gov. Hypothetical illustrations do not guarantee future results. Annuity guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.